
So one of the things I would like to at least keep some of my thoughts on are my first impressions of a book on finishing them. And I got a whole stack of notes I'm working on organizing but figured I would write out some quick thoughts on "The Shattering"
Its a good book. It really is by warcraft standards it is a great book. Like many of the more resent warcraft novels the book does feel like it has a check list of things to do but it does them without feeling contrived like Stormrage(which honestly had a much shorter list)
Item 1. Get Thrall out of Orgrimar
Item 2. Make Garrosh Hellscream Warchief
Item 3. Kill Cairne Bloodhoof
Item 4. Kill Magni Bronzebeard
Item 5. Make Anduin Wrynn intresting
Item 6. Get Thrall a Girlfriend.
Item 7. Set up the Cataclysm
Honestly feel there are few most things that might have been on the list but these are the big ones. Honestly the book is more about setting up the new political normal than it is setting up all the earth changing stuff. The biggest hit the book gives into the Cataclysm storyline is that the twilight cult is behind the attacks that cause the end of the truce between the Alliance and Horde.
In my mind the reason this book works so well is because everything has a good reason for what they do. Cairne challenges Garrosh to a battle to the death because Cairne thinks Garrosh is behind the attacks. While Garrosh is a hothead he is not an irrational hot head. As much as he has come to respect his father he doesn't want to be defined by his father. My biggest issue with the book is the meeting it Theramore between Baine Bloodhoof, Jaina Proudmoore, and Anduin Wrynn. Not to say it couldn't happen but only that by that point in the story it feels like your slowing the pace down. And other than killing some time in the novel and giving Baine the Dwarf mace. It just server as a wait to express some of the characters feelings in dialog rather than inner monologue. Its felt like they needed a way to tie the Alliance and the Horde story together. In that regard it works, but doesn't make it feel any less unnecessary.
Still great job of setting up the new normal. I look forward to the next book in the Cataclysm series if there is one. And if not just have to enjoy the game.
73's
